En engelsk katolsk sogneprest skriver i the Catholic Herald om hvordan den gamle messen fungerer i hans menighet – der ca 1/3 av søndagsmessebesøket er i denne messen.
Han sier at det ikke (egentlig) er biskoper som ønsker å bremse bruken av denne messen, men heller en stor prosent av alle katolikker. Han skriver så at hovedpoenget med å feire denne messen er at fokuset er så tydelig på å tilbe Gud, heller enn å underholdes (som man noen ganger ser i den nye messen, heldigvis mest i utlandet). Han gjør det også lettere for folk å bli vant til den gamle messen (etter 40 års fravær) ved å synge noen tradisjonelle salmer på morsmålet hver søndag, og ved alltid å lese tekstene på morsmålet.
Three years ago, in July 2007, the Holy Father published Summorum Pontificum giving parishioners the canonical right to have their parish priest celebrate the Old Form of Mass (the Extraordinary Form) for them alongside the New or Ordinary Form. In places Summorum Pontificum is resisted, and it is important to recognise and address the causes.
Some say the obstruction comes from bishops, but this is unfair. The problem seems to lie within the Church as a whole, being an aversion to formal, God-directed worship in favour of a liturgy that entertains with cheerful hymns, is undemanding to follow and casual in celebration. This aversion harbours resistance not only to Summorum Pontificum but even to the new translation of the New Form. As the end of the three year period of assessment on how the implementation of Summorum Pontificum has gone approaches, I offer a reflection from one of the several parishes which celebrate in the Old Form every Sunday.
In scheduling the Old Form, objections came mainly from those who experienced the heady days of the Church’s surge into change after Vatican Council II and who saw change and informality as the order of the day. It is understandably hard for them to welcome back their heritage when it evokes things considered long gone and appears to undo what was established by priests they have loved. But honesty compels us to acknowledge that we all abandoned things the Council decreed we retain, while loyalty demands we recover them by authentic catechesis on both the Council and the Ordinary Form. … …