På First Things kan vi lese en interessant artikkel om pave Frans, Artikkelen begynner slik:
He has been called an “improv pope,” a pope of many surprises, but the biggest surprise of all is that Francis continues to elude all efforts to classify him. Since the opening days of his papacy, a flood of commentators have come forth to tell us what to expect of him, only to miss the mark. Among the numerous errors about Francis, five in particular stand out.
1. “Francis is the anti-Benedict.”
Because Pope Francis is from Latin America, and Pope Emeritus Benedict from Germany—and because Francis is a natural extrovert and Benedict more reserved—some people thought that these stylistic differences signaled a difference in their whole way of thinking. But anyone who ever believed that was not being attentive. …
Og de andre fire punktene er de følgende:
2. “Francis is Not a Cultural Warrior.”
Following the first error flows a second: unlike the supposedly hard-edged Benedict, we have been told, Francis has a much softer touch. He avoids confrontation and strident denunciations, and wants no part of any culture war; nowhere is that clearer than in his treatment of the hot-button social issues. Religious reporter Allesandro Speciale recently wrote that Francis “has been less eager to engage in the culture wars over abortion or gay marriage cherished by his predecessors.” Sandro Magister added: “It cannot be an accident that after 120 days of pontificate Pope Francis has not yet spoken the words abortion, euthanasia, homosexual marriage.”
It’s hard to imagine more misleading statements than these. ….
3. “Francis is a ‘Social Justice’ Pope.”
When people say, as they often do, that Pope Francis is a “social justice pope,” what they invariably mean is that he cares about the poor above all else, and will focus his papacy on solving poverty. This is at once obvious and incomplete. Of course Francis, like his predecessors, cares about the poor, … …
4. “Francis Will Be More Charitable Toward Dissenters.”
No sooner was Francis elected than did dissenters start elevating him at the expense of his two predecessors, suggesting he would finally fulfill Vatican II’s promise. But Pope Francis does not see Vatican II as a charter for dissent any more than did Blessed John Paul II or Benedict. Francis has firmly said that to know Jesus is to be in full communion with the Church and Magisterium; …. ….
5. “Francis Loves the World.”
This is the greatest misconception of all. Francis, we are told, has an ease with the world that so many other religious leaders, fearful of modernity, lack. But this is not because Francis loves the world per se. Francis loves people, and wants to lead souls to Christ—and that is why he speaks so often about the devil, and warns against worldly temptation, urging us to flee it. …..
Der har vært en god del interessante linker angående og omhandlende Pave Frans(ciscus)på The Remnants hjemmeside nylig – med en stadig mere kritisk tone, hvilket kanskje ikke er så overraskende; dog kan jeg ikke ikke unngå å føle at man setter fingeren på en del potensielt svært problematiske ting. Det er derfor verdifullt at du presenterer en alternativ tolkning av hans pontifikat så langt, så får vi i mellemtiden ha et åpent sinn. Men jeg savner Benedikt….