1. januar kunngjorde pave Benedikt at han ville invitere ledere fra mange religioner til et nytt møte i Assisi i oktober i år, 25 år etter at et lignende møte først ble arrangert der, av pave Johannes Paul II. Noen likte dette første møtet godt, og andre mislikte det kraftig; fordi de mente det var altfor åpent for synkretisme. På www.chiesa kan vi lese om dette:
… Professor Roberto de Mattei … has joined other Catholic figures in signing an appeal to the pope that the new meeting in Assisi «not reignite the syncretistic confusion» of the first, the one convened on October 27, 1986, by John Paul II in the city of Saint Francis.
In effect, in 1986, then cardinal Joseph Ratzinger did not go to that first meeting, of which he was critical. He did, however, take part in a repeat of it held also in Assisi on January 24, 2002, agreeing «in extremis» after being assured that the mistakes of the previous meeting would not be made again.
The main mistake fostered by the meeting in Assisi in 1986 was that of equating the religions as sources of salvation for humanity. Against this error, the congregation for the doctrine of the faith issued in 2000 the declaration «Dominus Iesus,» reaffirming that every man has no other savior than Jesus.
But also as pope, Ratzinger has again warned against the confusion. In a message to the bishop of Assisi dated September 2, 2006, he wrote:
«In order not to misunderstand the meaning of what John Paul II wanted to accomplish in 1986, and what, in his own words, is described as the ‘spirit of Assisi’, it is important not to forget the attention that was paid at that time to prevent the interreligious prayer meeting from being subjected to syncretistic interpretations founded upon a relativistic conception. […] For this reason, even when we gather together to pray for peace, this prayer must be carried out according to the distinct approach that is proper to each of the various religions. This was the decision in 1986, and this decision cannot but remain valid today as well. The coming together of those who are different must not give the impression of a concession to that relativism that denies the very meaning of truth and the possibility of attaining it.” …
Pave Benedikt tok opp dette temaet på nytt igjen i Assisi i 2007 – les mer om dette hos www.chiesa.